Trinidad and Tobago Humanist Association

tt.humanist :: forum :: commentary :: religion

Spiritual and moral background checks for Police?

06 October 2009 • 356 words
Published in Express and International Humanist & Ethical Union

With police misbehaviour and corruption running rampant, one Anglican priest has proposed “spiritual and moral background checks” for applicants to the Police Service.

We wonder how such checks would be conducted. Would church attendance be considered sufficient evidence of good character? Or, by contrast, would any applicant who is having sex outside marriage be considered morally unfit to be a police officer, since fornication is a sin by religious lights? And how do you measure spirituality?

We would argue that imposing moral criteria, instead of emphasizing ethical principles, will either have no effect or actually worsen standards in the Police Service. This is particularly so since the religious criterion in the Service appears to be exclusively Christian. At a recent thanksgiving service, for example, Acting Commissioner James Philbert and his senior officers had Pentecostal pastor Winston Cuffie presiding. Their moral sensibilities were clearly not bothered by the unaccredited doctorate Pastor Cuffie puts before his name, but persons concerned with ethics would hardly consider this individual an exemplar.

In all branches of the Defence Force, it appears that prayers and oaths taken on Bibles have become unofficial criteria for entry to these bodies. Atheists and agnostics – who, by the way, are the least represented group among inmates in prison, as compared to Catholics, Baptists, Anglicans, Pentecostals, and Muslims – are thus either barred or at the very least made to feel alienated.

If the authorities really want to improve conduct in the Police Service, they should concentrate on rigorous psychological evaluations, on implementing measures to prevent “pull string” and bribery to gain entry to the Service, and on inculcating professional standards in recruits. As for religious belief, that should be a private matter for all officers since it has no effect on commitment and excellence on the job.

T&T Humanist Association

See There is no correlation between religion and ethics

See A dose of Darwin (Charles Darwin 200, Origin of Species 150)

See Myth, not history, from UWI academics

See Statement on TT Humanist Day 2008

See Should a leader impose belief over reason?

See TT Humanist : News : Launch : The Virtues of Secularism (PDF)



Commentary Articles Letters Opinions Discussion Feedback
Humanism Association Views Forum News Membership Resources Links
Home Contact Index Top
Copyright © Trinidad and Tobago Humanist AssociationTrinidad and Tobago Humanist Associatione-Mail